CENTRAL ASIA DOESN'T NEED INTEGRATION
We say that the goal of Central Asia is “unity”. When we say “unity”, the term “integration” in international relations immediately comes to mind. Integration is a process that leads to the unification of different countries, sometimes even to the creation of interstate associations in order to jointly achieve a common goal. And the creation of an interstate institutional organization means transferring part of your state's decision-making and implementation mechanisms to a supranational institution. And the Central Asian Five, who have achieved independence and are still in the process of creating a “nation-state,” are not ready, first of all, at the “conscious” level, to accept such a rule. The notion of “independence” is the most valued concept for the Central Asian states, and rightly so. However, the game of “strong players” in international relations explains that in order to maintain their “independence” they need “unity”, they need to form a strong region, and this region must have a common “immunity”. So how can we unite without giving importance to “consciousness” in the concept of “independence”?
In 2019, with the support of the Friedrich Ebert Foundation, a joint analytical work “Regionalization in Central Asia: Kazakhstan's Strategy” was published by Central Asian experts: Farhod Aminzhonov, Rustam Burnashev, Ikbolzhon Koraboev, Islam Kuraev, Kairat Moldashev, Gauhar Nurshi, Anastasia Reshetnyak, Andrey Chebotarev. When asked how to characterize the processes taking place in Central Asia, the authors replied: “If we talk about integration, it is usually understood as the creation of institutional forms of relations in the form of regional organizations. And simply talking about cooperation seems to be insufficient for the countries of the region, which have very close historical, cultural, economic and other ties. “Therefore, we propose to use the term 'Central Asian regionalization',” these writings conclude. These experts also understand the urgent need for “unity” and in search of a way also put forward the theses of “comfortable regionalism”. Simply put, it is about a slow, albeit slow, but qualitative “regionalization” that preserves “independence” and is carried out in a natural way, without harming anyone's internal values or upsetting “neighbors”. This conclusion, however, seems to have proved untenable. The proposal, while attractive, is too slow and time-consuming. In a rapidly changing and fluid international environment, contemporary geopolitical challenges do not suggest gradual “regionalization”. In recent years, neither at official meetings of Central Asian leaders nor in subsequent interviews has any Central Asian leader used the term “regionalism”.
The British scholar Filippo C. Buranelli, who has studied Central Asian processes extensively, began to propose the concept of a “Central Asian order” in 2021. In an interview with the Astana Times news portal in 2024, he expressed the opinion that the concept of “order” is closer to the processes taking place in Central Asia than the notions of “integration” or “regionalism”. However, this view has not yet found favor. Central Asian society probably feels threatened by the threat of “independence” even under the notion of a “general order”. Moreover, for the concept of a “Central Asian order” to work, state and non-state (civilian) structural systems must work together.
The presidents of Central Asian countries, meeting on August 8, 2024, signed a document of great importance for the future of the region. The document is called “Concept for the Development of Regional Cooperation ‘CENTRAL ASIA - 2040’. The term “integration” is not used in this document at all. Central Asian cooperation is described as a unique relationship based on mutual respect, mutual support, equality and good neighborliness.
The point is that there is no clearly defined formula, explanation or description of Central Asian relations. Only one thing is clear. Central Asia's goal is unity. We can preserve “independence” only through unity. Let us unite the five countries like the five fingers of one hand!
Duman Zhekenov