REVISION OF THE ARTICLE “GEOPOLITICAL ARITHMETIC ‘5+1’ BY F. TOLIPOV

In November 2020, the information portal CABAR.asia published an article by the famous Uzbek scientist Farhod Tolipov entitled “Geopolitical arithmetic of 5+1 in Central Asia”. This article has caused controversy in academic circles since its publication. Taking into account recent geopolitical changes and developments in the Central Asian region, we would like to revisit this article and offer it for discussion to the scientific community.

The essence of geopolitical arithmetic in the article is as follows: 5+1 is a system in which, in the case of the United States, the region itself is prioritized, i.e. 5+1=5; In the case of 5+1, Russia has the advantage, i.e. 5+1=6; In the case of China, there are unclear, ambiguous ratios, i.e. 5+1=x. According to him, the most important thing for Central Asia is the “5+0” formula, i.e. the region's own integration without other players.

UNITED STATES

The US policy towards Central Asia was based on two main documents. These are: the draft Silk Road Strategy, adopted in 1999, and the new U.S. Strategy for Central Asia for 2019-2025. USAID (United States Agency for International Development) has carried out a very effective set of works until the end of January 2025 to implement the main directions outlined in these documents. The Trump administration issued an executive order to temporarily suspend USAID's activities and conduct a comprehensive audit. Currently, the official websites of USAID are inaccessible in Kazakhstan. Only in 2024, Kazakhstan has been allocated $15.2 million with the support of this agency. Of this amount, $8.8 million was allocated only for the health sector. We would like to note that there are two different opinions regarding the termination of the agency's work in the region. For example, Kazakhstani expert D. Satpayev believes that “the main part of this empty space will be filled by China, and the remaining part by Russia”. This means that U.S. influence in the Central Asian region will be further reduced. There are also opinions that it is good that USAID has left the region.

The reason is that the activities of this agency mainly lead to all sorts of uprisings, referring to the fronts in Ukraine or the uprisings in Kyrgyzstan, in which the agency was actively involved. In any case, both the “Silk Road Strategy” adopted in 1999 and the strategy for 2019-2025 are outdated and expired. Moreover, the main plans and positions of the US administration's Central Asia policy under President Trump are still unclear. However, one thing is certain: Central Asia is not a very important geopolitical region for the United States. Therefore, the formula “5+1=5” according to F. Tolipov, who prioritizes the region, apparently means “5+1=x” or “5+1= SCO”. This is due to the fact that if the work of the U.S. agency is stopped, even temporarily, it is obvious that this space will be filled by competitors from China and Russia. Ultimately, if the U.S. enters the “5+1”, the situation in the region will either move into a phase of instability or the two main players, China and Russia, will continue their rivalry within the framework of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, turning it into polite cooperation.

RUSSIA

Relations in the format of Central Asia + Russia are developing further. At the time of publication of this article, meetings were held only at the level of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, but in 2022 the first summit with the participation of heads of state was organized. A second summit at this level is planned for 2025. The Russian Federation is actively developing bilateral and multilateral relations with the countries of the region in order to preserve and further strengthen its influence in the region. It is not true that the “5+1=6” formula has been canceled. That is, Russia's relations in the region are not in the phase of giving priority to the region, but in the phase of showing priority to the region. Therefore, the author's opinion about Russia in 2020 is still relevant. Our partner, Russia, will never build relations according to the “5+1=5” formula. If a Central Asian “five” is possible, this formula should be changed to “5+1=1+1”. That is, a single region and equal relations.

CHINA

We must recognize that it is the PRC that is most active and systematic in the Central Asia+ format. The productive high-level summit in Xi'an in 2023 and the opening of the Central Asia+China Mechanism Secretariat in Xi'an are concrete confirmation of our words. A second summit is planned in Kazakhstan in 2025. The PRC is making very effective use of geopolitical changes in the international arena. Factors such as Russia's prolonged state of war, the European Union's economic difficulties, and the U.S. temporary suspension of USAID create opportunities for China to increase its influence in the region. China's main competitors in Central Asia are themselves losing influence in the region, unable to absorb China's excessive power. Thus, we can say that the value of “x” in F. Tolipov's formula “5+1=x” is fully defined. The formula “5+1=(5)” seems to better describe China's relations in the region. That is, it is a relationship of equality, having only external manifestations in brackets, based not on the countries of the region, but on China's economic dominance in the region.

THE CENTRAL ASIAN “FIVE”

The author offers the following conclusions, proposing a “5+0” formula for Central Asian states:

- Central Asia does not need additional players. The zone is open for access but closed to the presence of an additional player;

- Reaching the level of the Organization of Central Asian States by strengthening the work of advisory councils;

- When regulating the relations of major players in the region, such as the U.S., Russia, or China, look not from the perspective of their interests, but from the perspective of the interests of the region or regional states;

- Ensuring that the presence of regional states in other organizations does not hinder the unification of the region.

It seems that an organization or union of Central Asian states is not a dream that will come true in the near future. Obviously, the political indifference of the regional states themselves, as well as the unwillingness of the major players to accept such a scenario, hampers integration processes. That is why the “5+0” formula is not working yet. On the contrary, regional leaders attach great importance to strengthening relations in the “5+1” format. In any case, Tolipov's last two statements should become a strict principle for the states of the region.

The goal of Central Asia is unity. We can preserve “independence” only through unity. Let us unite five countries like five fingers of one hand!

Duman Zhekenov 

P.S. We express our openness to scholarly discussion and debate.