COMPETITION BETWEEN RUSSIA AND CHINA IN CENTRAL ASIA
With the attainment of independence in 1991, the Central Asian states almost immediately became arenas for the intersection of vital geopolitical and geoeconomic interests of leading global and regional powers. A region previously integrated into the Soviet space found itself at the epicenter of strategic rivalry.
According to Johannes Linn, a nonresident senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, China seeks to create a “peaceful backyard” on its western borders, whereas Russia views Central Asia as part of its historical sphere of interest and actively engages the region through labor migration and economic ties. Turkey focuses on shared Turkic heritage, while Iran emphasizes linguistic and cultural ties with the Tajik people. The Islamic traditions of the region also link it to the Middle East and the broader Muslim world.
Economic development and political stability in Central Asia are important for its 81 million inhabitants and neighboring countries. The region is a key route for the transportation and export of energy resources, which affects the formation of regional alliances and development. Central Asia serves as a strategic bridge between Europe and Asia and has, over the past two decades, become a site of active geopolitical competition among major powers. Among them, Russia and China stand out, as their interests in the region intersect but do not always align. The aim of this article is to analyze the nature and characteristics of the competition for influence between Russia and China in Central Asia, as well as the regional states’ responses to this dynamic.
This analysis relies on the principles of neorealism, according to which states strive to maximize their influence and security within an anarchic international system. Central Asia is viewed as a space of power competition between great powers, where each actor seeks to minimize dependence and maximize control over resources and political decision-making.
Neorealism also explains the behavior of the regional states: despite limited resources, they seek to maintain sovereignty and strategic flexibility by balancing between Russia and China. Thus, regional interactions can be understood as a power dynamic in a multipolar environment, where structural factors—such as distribution of power, military capabilities, and economic dependency—determine the behavior of actors.
In this dynamic environment, Russia employs various instruments of "hard power," including military presence in Central Asian countries and the formation of bilateral and multilateral alliances that ensure its strategic influence in the region. In addition, Russia uses elements of "soft power," such as promoting the Russian language and educational programs, helping to maintain cultural ties and expand its influence.
Unlike Russia, China emphasizes economic tools, such as providing loans, building infrastructure, attracting direct investment, and offering economic assistance. These approaches allow China not only to strengthen its position in Central Asia but also to build sustainable economic ties with local states.
The Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) serves as an important platform for interaction between the two powers. Here, China’s and Russia’s interests partially align, but they also compete for regional leadership. This organization becomes an arena where both sides discuss strategic interests, but also a field of rivalry, highlighting the complexity of the geopolitical situation in Central Asia.
In such circumstances, it is important to note that Central Asian countries strive to balance between the two major powers, leveraging their interests to achieve their own goals and enhance their independence. Kazakhstan actively participates in both the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) and Chinese infrastructure projects. Uzbekistan, following a leadership transition, has demonstrated a pragmatic approach by developing relations with both partners. However, some Central Asian states, particularly Kyrgyzstan, have begun reducing purchases of Russian gas due to political factors and repression against migrant workers. Kyrgyzstan’s Foreign Minister, Jeenbek Kulubaev, announced plans to diversify gas supplies and advised labor migrants to avoid Russia. These changes in energy policy underscore the growing need for regional countries to find alternative energy sources and strengthen their economic ties with other states, which may lead to new opportunities for cooperation and development.
Russia’s position in the region remains relatively strong due to historical and cultural ties. However, its resources and capabilities are limited by economic difficulties and deteriorating relations with the West. Efforts to maintain influence often rely on military and political tools, which may raise concerns among regional countries about excessive dependence.
China, on the other hand, demonstrates a dynamic and flexible approach, but its model is often criticized for the lack of transparency in investment conditions and for creating debt dependence. The absence of political commitments may offer short-term advantages but raises long-term concerns about the consequences of domination by a single economic power.
Thus, both powers face limitations: Russia—due to declining appeal and economic weight; China—due to mistrust and the risks of debt influence. In turn, Central Asian states are increasingly seeking to diversify partnerships and strengthen their own sovereignty.
The competition between Russia and China in Central Asia remains moderate but is intensifying as China strengthens its position. Regional countries have managed to take advantage of the situation, but the long-term sustainability of this balance will depend on global transformations in international politics and economics. In an era of growing global uncertainty, it is important to consider how changes in the international environment may affect internal processes and strategic priorities of Central Asian states.
The ongoing rivalry between Russia and China in Central Asia remains uncertain but increasingly relevant. Although some analysts believe that China's economic ambitions do not directly threaten Russia, historical examples suggest that economic power often evolves into political influence. Despite strong trade ties and shared global interests, potential tensions between the two powers in the region may intensify. Meanwhile, competing infrastructure projects, such as the U.S.-backed IMEC, Turkey’s Development Road, and the Middle Corridor (TITR), signal a growing "corridor war," intensifying the strategic rivalry for regional dominance.
Farangis Kydyrbek