views: 268 viewer

THE FUTURE OF DEMOCRACY IN CENTRAL ASIA AND TURKMENISTAN: IS THERE ANY HOPE?

Democracy is not just a system of governance; it is a profound philosophical concept that envisions respect for human rights and freedoms, equality, and justice. One such philosophical definition was given by the 16th President of the United States, Abraham Lincoln: "Democracy is the government of the people, by the people, for the people." This principle is particularly relevant today for the countries of Central Asia. After the collapse of the Soviet totalitarian system, the countries of the region gained independence and began to seek their own path of development. On this path, the formation of democracy is a complex and multifaceted process.

The level of democracy in the countries of Central Asia continues to decline. This is the conclusion reached by experts at The Economist, who compiled the Democracy Index for 2024. Kyrgyzstan was recognized as the most democratic country in the region, while the worst situation was in Turkmenistan. The decline in the level of democracy is a global trend.

According to The Economist, two of the five Central Asian countries are among those with the lowest indicators. These countries are Turkmenistan and Tajikistan: "The Democracy Index has declined or remained unchanged in all Central Asian countries. Turkmenistan, with an index of 1.66, unchanged since 2020, ranks last in the region at 161st place. Tajikistan's index fell from 1.94 in 2023 to 1.83, placing the country at 159th. This is due to the deterioration of political participation indicators, as President Emomali Rahmon maintains complete control over the political system. Uzbekistan's index also declined in 2024 from 2.12 to 2.10, but the country rose two positions (146th) due to a significant deterioration in other countries."

According to the compilers of the ranking, Kyrgyzstan has the best (111th place) situation with democracy among the Central Asian countries. However, in 2024, the country worsened its previous indicators, falling to 3.52. In 2023, this figure was 3.72, and in 2022 it was 3.89. The main decline is associated with the deterioration of the electoral process and the increased pressure on the media. Kazakhstan, with an index of 3.08 and 118th place in the overall global index, remained in the group of authoritarian regimes, without changing its positions. The study notes that the crisis of democracy is observed not only in individual regions but also worldwide.

According to Kazakh political scientist Dosym Satpayev, the ranking compiled by The Economist corresponds to the real picture. The countries of Central Asia do not strive to democratize their regimes. On the contrary, in almost all of them, despite the presence of civil society, pressure on it is increasing.

The widespread disillusionment with democracy is confirmed by survey data underlying the index. The analysis of these data is important for understanding the reasons for public dissatisfaction with the current state of democracy. It is obvious that the existence of formal democratic institutions is not in itself sufficient to ensure public support, especially if these institutions have lost their real influence and ability to affect decision-making. Overall, the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) has annually analyzed the state of democracy in the world since 2006. The 2024 report covers 167 countries and territories, which are assessed according to five criteria (from 0 to 10): electoral process and pluralism, functioning of government, political participation, political culture, and civil liberties. As a result, countries are divided into four types: full democracies, flawed democracies, hybrid regimes, and authoritarian regimes.

One of the states with an authoritarian regime is Turkmenistan. Turkmenistan is one of the most closed and authoritarian states in Central Asia. As for the current state of democracy in the country, the situation is not just difficult, but one could say completely stagnant. According to The Economist, Turkmenistan ranks 161st in the Democracy Index with 1.66 points. This is one of the lowest indicators in the world. Judging by the news I study and monitor today, the Turkmen people are a society with suppressed political will, having lost trust in the government. The economic situation is also far from satisfactory: food shortages, unemployment, inflation – these are the realities that the population faces daily. However, all this is not reported in the state media; on the contrary, it is replaced by reports of "prosperity and stability" in the country, of очередные (next) contracts with foreign companies, and only about the очередные (next) meetings of the leadership. Many citizens, realizing the lack of a future in the country, are turning to emigration. The Turkmen authorities have further restricted opportunities to travel abroad, especially for young people and women. Such measures are a clear sign of the authorities' desire to maintain complete control over society.

Turkmenistan today is the country in Central Asia furthest from democracy. But this situation is not eternal. Interaction between the countries of the region, the spread of technology, the views of the new generation – sooner or later, I think, will bring a breath of change to Turkmenistan as well. Democracy is not a system imposed from the outside; it is a need that matures from within the people themselves. Therefore, internal civic activism, access to information, and the pursuit of education will be the key to Turkmenistan's future democratic possibilities.

Olzhas Baisalbek