views: 211 viewer

THE FUTURE OF RADIO FREEDOM: THREATS TO FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION IN CENTRAL ASIA AND TURKMENISTAN

On March 14, U.S. President Donald Trump signed an order to reduce the activities of the U.S. Agency for Global Media (USAGM), which oversees seven federal agencies, including Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (RFE/RL), Voice of America, and several other media outlets. Within seven days, each agency head must submit a report to the Presidential Budget Council confirming compliance with Trump’s order and explaining which components or functions of the agency are "legally mandated and to what extent." This decision could jeopardize the operations of the media corporation, which broadcasts in nearly 50 languages, potentially leading to the cessation of funding for Radio Free Europe.

A few hours after the order was issued, former BBC News correspondent and journalist Tara Palmeri published a letter from USAGM stating that the Congress-approved "grant for funding Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (RFE/RL) had been revoked." The letter was signed by Kari Lake, who had established herself as a senior advisor with the authority to act as USAGM's interim CEO.

RFE/RL President and CEO Steven Capus stated: "The 'cancellation of the grant agreement' for Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and the shutdown of RFE/RL after 75 years of work would be a major gift to America’s enemies."

International organizations, politicians, and experts support the media corporation Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and other American media outlets, whose existence is now under threat. Many human rights activists, independent media, and members of the region’s research community have expressed their cooperation with RFE/RL's Central Asian services.

If Radio Free Europe ceases operations, a "dictatorship of law and order" will take hold in the country. This means that the current dire situation of about thirty political prisoners will soon affect all of Kazakh society. "Perhaps then we will understand the value of freedom of speech as a nation," wrote Kazakh political scientist Shalkar Nursseitov.

"As a citizen of Uzbekistan and someone who has lived in authoritarian countries, I can say: ‘Radio Free Europe’ has always been a window into reality. In Uzbekistan, state media have long been limited to discussions of prosperity and well-being in the country, while in 2005, it was precisely ‘Radio Ozodlik’ that reported on the Andijan incident, investigated the crimes of Karimov's regime, and continued to expose corruption within Mirziyoyev’s family. In a country where information is strictly controlled, ‘Radio Ozodlik’ remains the primary source reflecting the real picture of events," stated Uzbek political scientist Galiya Ibragimova.

"How many media outlets offer broadcasts in Kyrgyz that meet international standards? Such organizations are not created overnight. And who covers international events? Can we now see the world through lies? If (freedom) is shut down, we will simply lie down and sink into domestic and foreign propaganda. Who wins?" noted Kyrgyz political scientist Ruslan Akmatbek.

Journalists from "Radio Ozodi and Voice of America" are resilient. They are talented and capable. Right now, things will be very difficult, but over time, they will be weakened. I say this with certainty because I experienced the same thing a month ago. The situation for everyone in Tajikistan will only get worse," said Tajik media critic Liliya Gaisina.

Meanwhile, the International Press Institute (IPI) condemned the Trump administration's decision to limit the effective dissemination of broadcasts from "Voice of America," "Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty," and "Radio Free Asia." IPI believes that this step could strengthen autocratic regimes worldwide by depriving millions of people of alternative and reliable sources of news and information. "This decision will have a significant negative impact on the ability of millions of people living in authoritarian states to bypass censorship and access alternative sources," said IPI Executive Director Scott Griffen. The organization called on the U.S. government to reverse this decision and ensure the safety of media operations and employees.

The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) also condemned Trump’s order. The New York-based organization reminds that more than a thousand employees of "Voice of America" have been forced to stop working, threatening to deprive millions of people worldwide of independent broadcasting.

Kaja Kallas, the High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, called the news of the United States ending funding for Radio Free Europe "sad," noting that this media outlet is "a beacon of democracy." "The current question is: Can we step in with our own finances to fill the void left by the U.S.? The answer to this question will not be automatic," Kallas said on March 17, adding that the EU would consider possible support options.

On March 24, a U.S. court will hold hearings on the lawsuit filed by "Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty" against the U.S. Agency for Global Media (USAGM). The company is demanding an immediate restoration of funding to avoid the "irreparable damage" caused by the delay of funds allocated by Congress. The case will be heard in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia at 2:00 PM local time.

Radio Free Europe is demanding that USAGM immediately allocate $7.5 million to cover funding from March 1 to March 15. The company also seeks full funding for the 2025 fiscal year, which ends on September 30. The main court hearing on this issue is scheduled for mid-April.

In general, Radio Free Europe is an independent American media corporation funded through a congressional grant via the U.S. Agency for Global Media. It broadcasts in 27 languages across 23 countries, including Turkmenistan and other Central Asian states. This media corporation is a vital source of information for citizens of Central Asia and other authoritarian countries.

Given that alternative information in Turkmenistan is heavily restricted, the closure of Radio Free Europe could negatively impact freedom of speech in the country. For Turkmenistan, this would mean the potential loss of one of the few alternative sources of information. Even under conditions of total censorship, the blocking of foreign media, and strict control over the internet, Radio Free Europe remained an important resource for Turkmen citizens, providing news about the country and the world. The Turkmen authorities have repeatedly tried to shut down the work of journalists associated with Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, but the broadcaster continued to cover important events.

If the operations of this media corporation are suspended, access to independent information in Turkmenistan may be further restricted, deepening the country’s informational isolation. As a result, this could negatively impact the development of freedom of speech and democratic processes in Turkmen society.

Olzhas Baisalbek