INTERNATIONAL CRITICISM AND THE INTERNAL SITUATION WITH RELIGIOUS FREEDOM IN TURKMENISTAN
Freedom of religion is an integral part of human rights. Freedom is a fundamental component of our essential spiritual qualities, such as conscience, reason, kindness, repentance, keeping one's word, and responsibility. Religion is an unshakable pillar of human spiritual development. The ultimate goal of religion is the improvement of the individual and their spiritual upbringing. It embodies kindness and compassion, doing one's best, and serving God with a pure and sincere heart.
Freedom of religion is one of the basic human rights, representing freedom of conscience and belief. This right allows each individual to adhere to any religion, freely practice their faith, or hold no beliefs at all. It is not limited to religious rituals but also includes the right to express opinions about religion, preach, establish religious organizations, and freely associate with them.
The formation of religious policy in Central Asian countries was primarily influenced by the anti-religious ideology and repressive practices of the Soviet period. In the USSR, atheism was established as the official ideology, and religion was removed from public life. Mosques and churches were closed, and religious figures were persecuted. Many religious institutions in Central Asia were destroyed, and religion survived only at the domestic level, practiced secretly.
After gaining independence in 1991, these countries entered a new spiritual space. Interest in religion increased, mosques and madrasas began to open, and foreign religious organizations became active in the region. However, this process was met with suspicion and caution by governments. Authorities sought to limit the socio-political influence of religion and created special laws and structures to control it.
Governments in Central Asia generally pursue policies that restrict freedom of religion under the guise of combating religious radicalism. However, these restrictions often appear more as tools for strengthening political regimes than as genuine efforts to combat radicalism. The relationship between religion and the state is a delicate matter. Excessive restrictions on religious freedom can lead to violations of fundamental citizens’ rights, while lack of control can lead to the rise of religious fanaticism. Therefore, maintaining a balance is an important task for any state.
The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) published its 2025 report. One of the key findings is that the deterioration of religious freedom and persecution is a global trend. This year, the number of countries designated as “Countries of Particular Concern” decreased by one. However, the number of countries recommended for inclusion in the “Special Watch List” increased by exactly one. This year, all Central Asian countries were listed as violators. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uzbekistan were placed on the “Special Watch List.” Turkmenistan and Tajikistan were, for the fifth consecutive year, designated as “Countries of Particular Concern.”
The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) is an independent, bipartisan advisory body of the U.S. government, separate from the State Department. Established by Congress on a bipartisan basis, the Commission monitors religious freedom worldwide and makes policy recommendations to the President, Secretary of State, and Congress.
Among the Central Asian states, the condition of religious freedom in Turkmenistan, which is listed as a “Country of Particular Concern,” was recognized last year as one of the worst in the world.
The government appoints religious leaders and strictly controls religious practices, persecuting followers of non-traditional religions who face imprisonment, torture, and pressure. Due to the closed nature of the state, documenting all violations of religious freedom is difficult, and it is evident that the actual number of violations exceeds what is reported in the limited available sources. The government maintains a large network of informants monitoring the activities of independent religious groups both inside and outside the country. Those accused of religious crimes often face closed trials, and verdicts are not made public. Convicted individuals often disappear in prisons and are prohibited from maintaining contact with the outside world. During the COVID-19 restrictions, mosques were closed to visitors, but this did not prevent memorial services from being held following the death of President Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov’s father. As a positive note, the report mentions the May 2021 pardon of all 16 Jehovah’s Witnesses who refused military service on grounds of conscience.
USCIRF recommends that the U.S. government: Maintain Turkmenistan’s designation as a “Country of Particular Concern” due to its severe and systematic violations of citizens’ right to religious freedom; Limit security assistance to the country due to its particularly egregious violations of religious freedom; Impose targeted sanctions against government agencies and officials responsible for gross violations of religious freedom, including travel bans and asset freezes; Urge the Turkmen government to introduce alternative civilian service and stop prosecuting individuals who refuse military service on religious grounds.
Despite varying trends in religious freedom across Central Asia, Turkmenistan has developed its own rigidly controlled system in this regard. The freedom of religious organizations and believers in the country is restricted and placed under total state control. For several years now, international organizations have listed Turkmenistan among the “Countries of Particular Concern.” This situation not only restricts citizens’ freedom of conscience but also tarnishes the country’s international reputation. Unless the Turkmen authorities change their stance, religious freedom in the country is unlikely to progress. However, change is possible—through not only external pressure but also the awakening of internal public consciousness.
Olzhas Baisalbek