“GLOBAL GOVERNANCE” AND HIDDEN IDEOLOGY: CHALLENGES FOR CENTRAL ASIA
Neoliberalism, considered a logical continuation of liberalism, became one of the dominant approaches in international relations theory by the end of the 20th century. In some cases, it is referred to as transnationalism as an independent theoretical school. Neoliberals view globalization processes—the formation of a unified economic, informational, and cultural space—as a positive phenomenon and, as a consequence of these processes, advance the concept of “global governance.”
The main representatives of this approach include M. Doyle, J. Rosenau, J. Nye, and R. Keohane. According to Robert Keohane and Joseph Nye, contemporary interstate relations are no longer based solely on military power. On the contrary, economic interdependence, international institutions, and “soft power” mechanisms are becoming increasingly significant. Military “hard power” is costly, whereas soft power allows for long-term influence.
The concept of “global governance” and regional reception
It is natural that the concept of “global governance” initially raises doubts in Central Asian states, as independence and sovereignty are highly sensitive issues in the region. However, this concept does not imply top-down control over states or the deprivation of their decision-making rights. Instead, it aims to coordinate relations between states through international norms, institutions, NGOs, and transnational corporations.
Nevertheless, the issue of “freedom of choice” raises new questions. Freedom of choice inherently involves the possibility of error. From this perspective, the question of how well Central Asian societies are equipped to make “correct choices” remains relevant. While neoliberal values are attractive, their indiscriminate implementation may lead to social and cultural contradictions.
“Individual responsibility” and social policy
Another important principle of neoliberalism is individual responsibility. This approach criticizes excessive government intervention not only in the economy but also in social spheres. Excessive social assistance is argued to weaken citizens’ motivation to work.
The U.S. experience is often cited to support this view. During the 1980s–1990s, some types of social benefits were reduced, which led to increased participation in the labor market. Interestingly, similar discussions have emerged in Kazakhstan in recent years. The President’s remarks on social dependency, incomplete family structures, and individual responsibility resonate with the neoliberal discourse.
However, there is a contradiction: while promoting individual responsibility, increased administrative control over small and medium-sized businesses hinders the full realization of this principle. This illustrates where neoliberal principles encounter regional realities.
Neoliberalism and Neorealism: The Central Asian Experience
The idea of “global governance” is considered one of the main initiatives of neoliberalism in international relations theory. In contrast, neorealism emphasizes the decisive role of the balance of power and national security in international politics. According to Kenneth Waltz, the founder of neorealism, international institutions are merely instruments dependent on the will of states.
The Central Asian experience demonstrates both the limitations and benefits of these perspectives. Kazakhstan’s nuclear disarmament initiatives, active engagement in the UN, and water diplomacy illustrate the effectiveness of neoliberal mechanisms, whereas the influence of powers such as Russia, China, and the U.S. in regional security matters shows the predominance of neorealist logic.
Therefore, the most effective approach for the region is a hybrid model, combining both geopolitical power balance and institutional cooperation.
Hidden ideology and theoretical issues
Over the past twenty years, critical perspectives on international relations theories have intensified. The hidden ideological content of classical “Western” theories is often highlighted. Even F. Fukuyama acknowledged that there were exaggerations in the development of liberalism.
Canadian scholar Robert Cox made a famous statement addressing this issue: “Theory is always written for someone and for a specific purpose.” In other words, theory is never neutral. Regarding Central Asia, Western, Russian, or Chinese works each depict the region in accordance with their own interests.
From this perspective, it is insufficient to interpret the region’s future solely through external theoretical lenses. The formation of a Central Asian theoretical school that considers nomadic heritage, post-Soviet transformation, geographic location, and internal social forces is a pressing necessity.
Conclusion
The idea of “global governance” represents both an opportunity and a challenge for Central Asia. While its institutional cooperation mechanisms are important for economic development, neglecting cultural, social, and political specificities may lead to negative consequences. Similarly, understanding the hidden ideological nature of international relations theories paves the way for developing a scientific approach aligned with the region’s interests.
The central question remains open: Should Central Asia rely on external theoretical frameworks, or develop its own indigenous scientific perspective?
The aspiration of Central Asia is unity. Independence can only be preserved through solidarity. Let the five states be united, like the five fingers of one hand!
Duman Zhekenov
P.S. We express openness to scholarly discussion and debate.